cures for chlamydiapain relief online doctors prescriptionsativan cheapbody building nutritionno prescription lorazepamtreating high uric acidface cream for brown spotsbuy levitra no prescriptiondiuretics prescriptionhair loss womanallergic fungal sinusitisphentermine and online prescriptionsnatural contraception ukbodybuilding drugcialis usa pharmacybuy ativan without prescriptionantiviral drugs for fluprescription allergy medstreat diabetesdog antibioticsnatural stop smokingaids current treatmentcialis drug interactionbuy cheap generic viagraprozac treatmentfluconazole 100 mgfree penis enlargerparkinson disease treatmentmanaging painimipramine hclcelexa medicinebuy diet pills in ukliver failure edemasertraline 100mgdiscount levitra onlineosteoporosis drugbreast enlargement pills on salecauses of chest paininflammatory skinchinese muscle relaxantsinternal parasitesdiabetes productsmuscles of the bodynatural herbs to lower cholesterolviamax pure powertreatments for fluid retentionhow to lose asthmareal viagrabenicar tabletsbenicar 20 mgcalcium vitamin d for osteoporosisbuy mexiletinefast weight loss pillstramadol for depressionneisseria gonorrheairregular heart ratebuying condomsacne scar natural treatmenthome tooth whitening systemshow to cure acneambien prescriptionslight therapy for leukemiamedication for smoking cessationrobaxin dosagecheap birth control pilllevitra consultationbuy pepcidmedication for sinus infectionburn fat fastonline pain medshcl mg tramadolmuscle mass lossbronchial asthma remedycrestor lipitor vsbuy aristocortantidepressant medicationsdoctor us prescribe pain medicationcla supplementsale stop smokinghair re-growth productsimpotence support groupslong term prozac usecheapest price on phenterminecialis new zealandno prescription pharmacy valiumnatural cure for fluid retentionallergy medication safe in pregnancytooth whitening costbuy oxybutyninantihistamine loratadineprescription free viagracontraception and women's healthnatural tooth whiteningonline medication uk legalgeneric viagra overnight deliverycialis reactionbupropion mgprofessional tooth whitening bostonprotein muscle masshypnosis to stop smokingbuy cheap clonazepam without a prescriptionbuy acto plusbreast enhancement informationzithromax costdiltiazem 120 mgcheap ambien overnightfemale enhancing drugsgeneric for valtrexfluid retention presciption drugsmuscle spasm medicationmigraine remediestamiflu salefemale enhancement creamseffects of antidepressantspain medclomid success ratesativans overdosediscount birth control pillsclonazepamimipramine side effectsbest blood pressure drugsbodybuilding drugmexican discount drugsallergic cough remedypain killer without prescriptionbenefits of contraceptionnatural vitamin storestomach painsosteoporosis alternative treatmentsimpotence support groupsosteoporosis exercise vitamin d calciumcelexa withdrawalirregularity constipation stooloral pain reliefzocor medicineonline pharmacy mexicoprimrose oilhairball formula cat foodback pain relief productstreatment of ischemic stroksafest pain medsbenefits of coq10phentermine hydrochloriderapid weight loss pills for salebuy tretinoindiscount pet medrhinocort nasal sprayamoxicillin without a prescriptiontreatment of chickenpoxdog skin ailmentsi need viagra todaypurchase paxil onlinegeneric cholesterol medicationsovulation with clomidanti wrinklesroadrunner pharmacybladder controlblood clot leg painviagra online overnight deliverygeneric compazinebuy cheap viagra softprescription weight loss medicationchemo nausea remediesprozac paxil zoloftfluconazole medicationretin a gelgeneric cholesterol medsbentyl medicationhair loss drugscanadian top carb blockersimpotence herbsorder avandametskin treatmentcialis for meninsomnia drugswhat is tramadol 50 mgbest tooth whitening systemsincrease bust exercisestopping epilepsy medicationbreast enhancement orlandotadalafil buysoma 350mglist of medication used for diabetesnon prescription pain relieversacne skin carezantac onlinebuy stress gumdoes vigrx work?denver teeth whiteningprescription free viagrahome remedies for breast enlargementeffectiveness of clarinexherbal weight loss supplementsbuy diabetes medicinewellbutrin effectswhat is cialis professionalwhat is methotrexatespironolactone side effectsskin care productorder vpxlpain relief for severe sinus migrainedog gallbladder problemsgeneric cialis softtabs


Columnist | David J. Sanders

Experience and expertise thrown out the door

By David J. Sanders

Unfortunately for Gary Voigt and Richard Ford, their contributions to the Governor’s Commission on Global Warming were not what they had hoped for or expected. Both men brought with them significant expertise and experiences, along with solid reputations, which, in the end, should have enhanced the commission’s work.

Voigt leads the state’s Electrical Cooperatives and has worked with numerous national organizations and on task forces aimed at leading the country toward energy efficiency. Ford is a respected environmental economist and from his post at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock has spent years publishing, studying and teaching.

But both men recognized problems early on.

“The commission members themselves weren’t as big of participants as was CCS, quite frankly,” Voigt said. CCS is the Center for Climate Strategies, which has been revealed in this space to have dominated the GCGW’s work from start to finish. “Commission members didn’t have the input; CCS’s consultants had most of the input. There was a structure and a goal.”

Voigt explained that before the commission started its work, McKinsey & Company, the venerable business consulting firm, released a study outlining cost-efficient methods of reducing greenhouse gases. That study, for Voigt, would have been a logical starting place or, at least, a good resource for the GCGW. “My thought was ‘Let’s do those things that reduce cost, reduce the need for new capacity and transmission, before we go to the other side of the curve where we begin to pay big dollars for strategies with questionable benefits,’” he said.

Ford saw looming problems, both with CCS’s involvement and their processes, which commission members eventually approved, although CCS’s methods lacked standard analytics, which are part of environmental economics. Ford explained that in order to perform a true economic analysis of the policy recommendations, both “allocative and technical” efficiencies had to be quantified.

He explained to the commission the necessity for measuring both efficiencies, but nothing changed. “A true economic analysis was never done,” he said, which is why he voted against every policy proposal that claimed to have a cost savings.

Within the CCS/GCGW report, many of the 54 policy recommendations were assigned a cost and a savings number that was calculated in dollars per million metric tons of CO2, which Voigt said was “worse than worthless.”

Referencing studies from the Electric Power Research Institute, he explained that if the industry continues to make investments in existing and emerging technologies, then they could reduce the levels of CO2 emissions by 45 percent by 2030. He said that preferred approach would result in a 50 percent increase in cost to ratepayers during that period.

Conversely, Voigt pointed out that by adopting the Kyoto Protocols or the same types of renewable energy portfolio mandates, cap-and-trade agreements and CO2 taxes CCS advocates, ratepayers would see a 260 percent increase in energy costs with roughly the same reduction in emissions as without mandates.

Voigt said studies show that the impact temperatures between the two approaches is negligible — only .07 degrees centigrade.  “If you do it right, we can achieve the same goal at low cost to the economy. If we do it wrong we could destroy the economy effectively,” he said.

In light of that information, he thought the GCGW would consider these “rational strategies,” which would “get us to the same place” in terms of reduction in carbon emissions. But when he shared the data with the commission, “Everyone said, ‘that’s a good idea’ and then we went back to the CCS agenda.”

Why would anyone prefer the more costly approach? “You have to ask the question, ‘what is CCS’s objective?’” which he said isn’t to reduce CO2, but rather to push “carbon taxes, cap-and-trade schemes and RPS standards.”

For Voigt it’s simple; besides the well-meaning environmental ideologues, there are some individuals and organizations that are pushing mandates because they stand to benefit financially.

Click here to read John Lyon’s report on the meeting scheduled for Wednesday, January 14, 2008 concerning the Governor’s Commission on global warming.

——-
David Sanders writes twice weekly for the Arkansas News Bureau in Little Rock and is a host of the Arkansas Education Television Network’s “Unconventional Wisdom.” His e-mail address is DavidJSanders@aol.com.

0 Comments For This Post

6 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Critics to give minority report on climate change | Arkansas News Says:

    [...] Click here to read columnist David J. Sanders’ latest column dealing with the Governor’s… « Bill targets illegal immigration OPPOSITION FORMING TO CIGARETTE TAX » [...]

  2. Sanders on ARGOCOGLOWARM: Experts Need Not Apply | The Arkansas Project Says:

    [...] in long-ago 2008— on the Arkansas Governor’s Commission on Global Warming (ARGOCOGLOWARM) continues today with a look at how those with experience and expertise in dealing with climate chang… from the commission’s [...]

  3. Sanders on ARGOCOGLOWARM: Experts Need Not Apply | Arkansas News Says:

    [...] in long-ago 2008— on the Arkansas Governor’s Commission on Global Warming (ARGOCOGLOWARM) continues today with a look at how those with experience and expertise in dealing with climate chang… from the commission’s [...]

  4. Brother Sanders Travelin’ Global Warming Show | Arkansas News Says:

    [...] prove that he does believe in recycling, Arkansas News Bureau columnist David Sanders brought his fifth installment of his continuing saga on the Governor’s Commission on Global Warming to his readers today. I [...]

  5. Brother Sanders Travelin’ Global Warming Show (UPDATE - No Questions Allowed!) | Arkansas News Says:

    [...] prove that he does believe in recycling, Arkansas News Bureau columnist David Sanders brought his fifth installment of his continuing saga on the Governor’s Commission on Global Warming to his readers today. I [...]

  6. News Affecting Arkansas High Schools for 01/17/2009 « Arkansas High Schools Says:

    [...] Title: Experience and expertise thrown out the door | Arkansas News [...]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Advertise Here
  • Latest
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Subscribe
Advertise Here