cures for chlamydiapain relief online doctors prescriptionsativan cheapbody building nutritionno prescription lorazepamtreating high uric acidface cream for brown spotsbuy levitra no prescriptiondiuretics prescriptionhair loss womanallergic fungal sinusitisphentermine and online prescriptionsnatural contraception ukbodybuilding drugcialis usa pharmacybuy ativan without prescriptionantiviral drugs for fluprescription allergy medstreat diabetesdog antibioticsnatural stop smokingaids current treatmentcialis drug interactionbuy cheap generic viagraprozac treatmentfluconazole 100 mgfree penis enlargerparkinson disease treatmentmanaging painimipramine hclcelexa medicinebuy diet pills in ukliver failure edemasertraline 100mgdiscount levitra onlineosteoporosis drugbreast enlargement pills on salecauses of chest paininflammatory skinchinese muscle relaxantsinternal parasitesdiabetes productsmuscles of the bodynatural herbs to lower cholesterolviamax pure powertreatments for fluid retentionhow to lose asthmareal viagrabenicar tabletsbenicar 20 mgcalcium vitamin d for osteoporosisbuy mexiletinefast weight loss pillstramadol for depressionneisseria gonorrheairregular heart ratebuying condomsacne scar natural treatmenthome tooth whitening systemshow to cure acneambien prescriptionslight therapy for leukemiamedication for smoking cessationrobaxin dosagecheap birth control pilllevitra consultationbuy pepcidmedication for sinus infectionburn fat fastonline pain medshcl mg tramadolmuscle mass lossbronchial asthma remedycrestor lipitor vsbuy aristocortantidepressant medicationsdoctor us prescribe pain medicationcla supplementsale stop smokinghair re-growth productsimpotence support groupslong term prozac usecheapest price on phenterminecialis new zealandno prescription pharmacy valiumnatural cure for fluid retentionallergy medication safe in pregnancytooth whitening costbuy oxybutyninantihistamine loratadineprescription free viagracontraception and women's healthnatural tooth whiteningonline medication uk legalgeneric viagra overnight deliverycialis reactionbupropion mgprofessional tooth whitening bostonprotein muscle masshypnosis to stop smokingbuy cheap clonazepam without a prescriptionbuy acto plusbreast enhancement informationzithromax costdiltiazem 120 mgcheap ambien overnightfemale enhancing drugsgeneric for valtrexfluid retention presciption drugsmuscle spasm medicationmigraine remediestamiflu salefemale enhancement creamseffects of antidepressantspain medclomid success ratesativans overdosediscount birth control pillsclonazepamimipramine side effectsbest blood pressure drugsbodybuilding drugmexican discount drugsallergic cough remedypain killer without prescriptionbenefits of contraceptionnatural vitamin storestomach painsosteoporosis alternative treatmentsimpotence support groupsosteoporosis exercise vitamin d calciumcelexa withdrawalirregularity constipation stooloral pain reliefzocor medicineonline pharmacy mexicoprimrose oilhairball formula cat foodback pain relief productstreatment of ischemic stroksafest pain medsbenefits of coq10phentermine hydrochloriderapid weight loss pills for salebuy tretinoindiscount pet medrhinocort nasal sprayamoxicillin without a prescriptiontreatment of chickenpoxdog skin ailmentsi need viagra todaypurchase paxil onlinegeneric cholesterol medicationsovulation with clomidanti wrinklesroadrunner pharmacybladder controlblood clot leg painviagra online overnight deliverygeneric compazinebuy cheap viagra softprescription weight loss medicationchemo nausea remediesprozac paxil zoloftfluconazole medicationretin a gelgeneric cholesterol medsbentyl medicationhair loss drugscanadian top carb blockersimpotence herbsorder avandametskin treatmentcialis for meninsomnia drugswhat is tramadol 50 mgbest tooth whitening systemsincrease bust exercisestopping epilepsy medicationbreast enhancement orlandotadalafil buysoma 350mglist of medication used for diabetesnon prescription pain relieversacne skin carezantac onlinebuy stress gumdoes vigrx work?denver teeth whiteningprescription free viagrahome remedies for breast enlargementeffectiveness of clarinexherbal weight loss supplementsbuy diabetes medicinewellbutrin effectswhat is cialis professionalwhat is methotrexatespironolactone side effectsskin care productorder vpxlpain relief for severe sinus migrainedog gallbladder problemsgeneric cialis softtabs


Categorized | Arkansas News Bureau, News

Oral arguments heard in capital murder suspect’s double jeopardy claim

By John Lyon
Arkansas News Bureau

LITTLE ROCK — The constitutional prohibition against double jeopardy protects a Jefferson County man from being tried on a capital murder charge after a previous attempt to try him ended in a mistrial, the man’s attorney argued Thursday before the state Supreme Court.

An attorney for the state told the court the double jeopardy clause does not apply in the case of Glen Homer Shelton Jr., who ran over Melonie Hughes with a farm tractor near Pine Bluff on May 5, 2007.

The state’s highest court heard oral arguments Thursday in Shelton’s appeal of a Jefferson County circuit judge’s ruling denying his claim that taking his case to trial again would place him in double jeopardy.

Jefferson County Circuit Judge Robert Wyatt Jr. declared a mistrial in February 2008 after Shelton’s public defender, Tim Bunch, said in his opening statement that Shelton accidentally ran over Hughes. Chief Deputy Prosecutor Kyle Hunter argued at the time that Bunch’s statement contradicted the defense’s stated strategy, that Shelton killed Hughes in self-defense.

Bunch said in his opening statement that Hughes approached Shelton on the farm where he was working, and the two got into an argument. He said Hughes fired a gun at Shelton several times, and Shelton got onto a tractor and chased Hughes off the property before losing control of the tractor and striking Hughes.

Hunter said in his opening statement the tractor traveled more than 600 feet from the spot where it had been parked before striking Hughes in the middle of U.S. 425 south of Pine Bluff.

A .22 caliber revolver and seven expended cartridges were found near Hughes’ body.

Little Rock attorney Thomas Sullivan, who is handling Shelton’s appeal, told the Supreme Court Thursday that it was the prosecutor, not Shelton’s trial lawyer, who first mentioned the accident theory to the jury.

Sullivan said Hunter, who gave his opening statement first, told jurors they would hear that Shelton gave authorities several different explanations for the incident, including a claim that he accidentally ran over Hughes.

Sullivan argued that the prosecutor wanted a mistrial because he realized a capital murder conviction was unattainable.

“This is the most egregious overcharging I’ve ever seen in a capital context,” he said.

Deborah Gore, an attorney with the state attorney general’s office, said that because the judge believed the defense’s strategy was based on a claim of self-defense, he allowed Bunch to tell jurors that Hughes had drugs in her system at the time of the incident and had attacked Shelton with a knife in 2004.

The judge would not have allowed the “muddying of the victim” if he had known the defense planned to claim that Hughes’ death was an accident, Gore said.

“He (Bunch) misrepresented to the judge what his defense would be,” she said, adding that Bunch’s opening statement unfairly prejudiced the jury.

Justice Donald Corbin asked Gore who first put the notion of an accident into the jury’s minds. Gore acknowledged that it was the prosecutor who first mention the accident theory.

“You have broached the subject first, and we have case law after case law that says once you open it up, they can respond to it,” Corbin said.

Gore said the judge never ruled that the accident theory could not be mentioned, but if Bunch wanted to use the theory as a defense, he was obliged to say so before the trial.

The Supreme Court did not immediately issue a ruling.

Sullivan told reporters Shelton has been in jail for two years awaiting trial. He said that if Shelton had been convicted of manslaughter — a more appropriate charge than capital murder, according to Sullivan — he likely would have been released from prison after about two years.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Advertise Here
  • Latest
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Subscribe
Advertise Here